Daily News Analysis

Growth charts — WHO standards versus India crafted

stylish_lining

Background: Child undernutrition has been a persistent issue in India, and its determinants are diverse, encompassing factors such as food intake, dietary diversity, health, sanitation, women's status, and the overarching context of poverty. The primary measures for childhood undernutrition, including stunting (chronic undernutrition) and wasting (acute undernutrition), rely on anthropometric standards such as height-for-age and weight-for-height. Monitoring these indicators is crucial for assessing actual progress. India, like many other nations, adopts the World Health Organization (WHO) Growth Standards as a global benchmark for measuring malnutrition. However, there is an ongoing debate regarding various aspects of using these growth standards in the Indian context.

Issues:

MGRS as the base

  • The MGRS aimed to establish growth standards for children (from birth to five years) in healthy environments, as opposed to growth references based on U.S. children, many of whom were formula-fed.
  • The MGRS sample for India was drawn from privileged households in South Delhi, meeting specific criteria like a favorable growth environment, breastfeeding, and non-smoking mothers.
  • Some researchers argue that MGRS standards may overestimate undernutrition in India, but valid comparisons require datasets meeting MGRS criteria, challenging due to inequality and underrepresentation of the rich in large-scale surveys.
  • Even among children in the highest quintile households, only a small percentage meets the WHO-defined 'minimum acceptable diet.'
  • Comparisons with MGRS could be misleading as it involved counseling for appropriate feeding practices, absent in other surveys like NFHS or Comprehensive National Nutrition Survey.

Genetic growth and other concerns

  • Issues with MGRS standards include differences in genetic growth potential among Indians and the influence of maternal heights on child growth.
  • Maternal height is a non-modifiable factor influencing child growth, reflecting intergenerational transmission of poverty and women's poor status.
  • Stunting, as an indicator of a deficient environment, should capture deprivation, but questions arise regarding the plasticity and usefulness of the standard.
  • Some countries with similar or poorer economic conditions show higher improvements in stunting prevalence using WHO-MGRS standards.
  • Regional differences within India, as well as shifts in gene pools with socioeconomic development, challenge the immutability of genetic potential.
  • Concerns about inappropriately high standards leading to misdiagnosis and potential overfeeding under government programs are raised, but improving meal quality can address these fears.
  • Dietary gaps, poor coverage of nutritional programs, and the need for diverse interventions like better sanitation, healthcare, and childcare services are emphasized.
  • Distal determinants of stunting, such as livelihoods, poverty, education, and women's empowerment, require attention for overall development and equitable Resource distribution.
  • Acknowledgment that individual children grow uniquely, and trained health personnel can interpret growth charts for individual care, while population trends are understood using appropriate standards for international and intra-country comparisons.

Recommendations of ICMR

  • The Indian Council of Medical Research has formed a committee to update the growth references for India. Reports indicate that this committee proposes a comprehensive and thorough study nationwide to assess child growth, aiming to create national growth charts if deemed necessary.
  • While obtaining more accurate and recent data on child growth is a positive step—especially in light of ambitious developmental goals to reach every individual by 2047 and the benefits of comparability—it appears reasonable to adhere to the aspirational yet attainable standards put forth by the WHO-MGRS.
  • Therefore, while gathering detailed national data is a positive step, retaining the WHO-MGRS as a temporary reference point seems prudent. This ensures continued focus on ambitious but achievable goals for child health and development, aligning with India's vision for the future.

 

World Health Organization (WHO)

  • The World Health Organization (WHO), established in 1948 as the specialized health agency of the United Nations, has its headquarters located in Geneva, Switzerland.
  • With 194 Member States, six regional offices, and 150 country offices, WHO operates as an inter-governmental organization. It collaborates with its member states, typically through their Ministries of Health.
  • WHO plays a crucial role in global health by offering leadership, shaping health research priorities, establishing norms and standards, formulating evidence-based policy recommendations, providing technical assistance to countries, and monitoring and evaluating health trends.
  • World Health Day, celebrated annually on April 7, marks the commencement of WHO's operations.

Multicentre Growth Reference Study (MGRS)

  • The WHO Multicentre Growth Reference Study (MGRS) was undertaken between 1997 and 2003 to generate new growth curves for assessing the growth and development of infants and young children around the world.
  • The MGRS collected primary growth data and related information from approximately 8500 children from widely different ethnic backgrounds and cultural settings (Brazil, Ghana, India, Norway, Oman and the USA).
  • The new growth curves are expected to provide a single international standard that represents the best description of physiological growth for all children from birth to five years of age and to establish the breastfed infant as the normative model for growth and development.

Visakhapatnam Declaration on e-Governance

The Visakhapatnam Declaration on e-Governance marks a significant step in the development of digital governance in India, emphasizing inclusive, transparent, and citizen-centric practices. Adopted
Share It

Defamation in India

Recently, a Supreme Court judge raised concerns about the increasing misuse of defamation laws by political figures and private individuals to settle personal and political disputes. The judge sug
Share It

Simultaneous Elections

India's ongoing debate about simultaneous elections or the One Nation, One Election concept has gained momentum, with experts like Arvind Panagariya, Chairman of the 16th Finance Commission, e
Share It

Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) 2025 Summit

The 2025 SCO Heads of State Summit was held in Tianjin, China, marking a significant moment for the organization’s expanding role on the global stage. Key Highlights: Terrorism:
Share It

Production Gap Report 2025

The Production Gap Report 2025 reveals a troubling trend: many countries are planning to increase fossil fuel production well beyond the levels needed to limit global warming to 1.5°C as per t
Share It

India's Roadmap for Fusion Power

India's Institute for Plasma Research (IPR) in Gandhinagar has recently proposed a comprehensive roadmap for the development of fusion power, marking a significant leap towards harnessing fusi
Share It

Dhvani Missile

India's Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) is on the verge of a historic milestone with the upcoming test of Dhvani, a next-generation hypersonic missile that is set to prope
Share It

Global Innovation Index (GII) 2025

India has made remarkable strides in the field of innovation, moving up from 48th position in 2020 to 38th in 2025 among 139 global economies, according to the World Intellectual Property Organiza
Share It

Critical Minerals

India’s first auction of deep-sea blocks for the extraction of critical minerals has been delayed indefinitely after receiving a poor response from bidders. This auction was expected to be a
Share It

CAG Report on States’ Fiscal Health

The Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG) has released its first decadal analysis on the fiscal health of 28 Indian states, revealing significant concerns over the increasing public debt.
Share It

Newsletter Subscription


ACQ IAS
ACQ IAS