Daily News Analysis

The narrative of development and populism

stylish_lining

The narrative of development and populism

 

Why in the News?

With election is round the corner in many states, and the General elections to be held in 2024, many developmental schemes and promises are given by various political parties.

Development and populism:

  1. In the election-bound State of Madhya Pradesh, the Prime Minister laid the foundation stone of projects worth over ₹50,700 crore. Few days later, a major opposition party of the state announced “guarantees” that included ₹2,500 financial assistance women every month, gas cylinders at ₹500, free travel for women in State transport buses, etc.,
  2. Such conjunction of ‘development and populism’ gain wide circulation before elections, as they are pitched as poll promises to evaluate the gains with respect to short-term versus long-term benefits.
  3. While development is the long-term ideal and populism is dubbed as myopic.

The development obsession:

  1. The poll promises of accelerated development often do not take up the issue of unevenness in welfare gains and inclusivity to understand the implications for welfare and sustainability in the post-poll time period. 
  2. Developments are often defined in narrow terms of visible physical infrastructure, so that it can be easily showcased and achievements can be quantified.
  3. The opposing political parties then have 3 options:
    1. To promise an even higher scale of infrastructure creation if voted to power.
    2. To highlight the unsuitability of the created infrastructure and dub it as failure
    3. To address welfare of some section of the population that is left out through economic populism.
  4. When development is equated to visible mega-infrastructure, it can lead to a dangerous obsession:
    1. The suitability of mega projects for the specific geographic location or users is often overstated without realistically assessing long-term environmental consequences and its implications on the livelihoods of present and future generations. 
    2. Financing mega-infrastructure are often on the assumption of exaggerated revenue accruals and flattened costs, which would surface as fiscal burden in medium term and impose additional costs to handle it.

 

The examples of projecting mega-infrastructure as development symbols, resulting in environmental disasters include:

      1. Himachal Pradesh, for instance, faced over 41 landslides, 29 flash floods, and one cloud burst during the period June 24 to July 10, 2023. Though it can be called as events of ‘climate crises’, the state has involved in ‘development’ through the construction of several highway roads connecting various tourist locations, thereby making the mountain regions fragile and unleashing unplanned urbanisation.
      2. Without learning lessons from the 2013 disaster, the state proceeded to rebrand development through construction of highway projects such as Char Dham Yatra, a road connectivity project to religious places beyond its carrying capacity.
  1. Results of such obsession:
    1. The easy route of development without sound scientific basis, selected by the policy regimes sets off a spiral of calamities. 
    2. It shall cost a huge financial burden and imposes long-term constraints.
      1. For instance, the total debt of the NHAI stood at ₹3,42,801 crore as on March, 2023, up from ₹23,797 crore in 2014. 

Space for populism

  1. Populism has the trait of claiming to represent and speak for ‘the people,’ which is assumed to be unified by a common interest.
  2. This common will is directed against the ‘enemies of the people’
    1. Minorities and foreigners (in the case of right-wing populists)
    2. Financial elites (in the case of left-wing populists). 
  3. Growth of political populism requires rules and restraints, while a fine blend of rules with discretion is required to curtail the expansion of economic populism.

On conventional models

  1. Conventional models of economic growth believed in ‘trickle-down effect’ or growth characterised by ‘high tide that lifts all boats’, where the element of populist re-distributive policies does not find a place.
  2. It bases the view that distribution was expected to be an inbuilt consequence of growth. 
  3. However, cross-country growth experience shows poor progress in automatic re-distribution and some sections of the population become ‘outliers’ in the growth process. 
  4. This emphasises the need for government-led redistribution to reduce the size of such outliers and spread the benefits of growth more evenly, which can be achieved through economic populism. 

Indian Ports Act, 2025

Why is the Indian Ports Act, 2025 in the News? The President of India has granted assent to the Indian Ports Act, 2025, which replaces the previous Indian Ports Act of 1908. This new Act aims t
Share It

Private Sector in Defense Production

The growth in private sector participation in India's defense production marks a significant shift in the country’s defense strategy and industrial landscape. The private sector share in
Share It

India-Mauritius

The visit of the Prime Minister of Mauritius to Varanasi marked a significant milestone in strengthening the India-Mauritius bilateral ties. Describing India as a trusted partner in Mauritius'
Share It

solar manufacturing ecosystem

India's ambitious plan to develop a fully indigenous solar manufacturing ecosystem by 2028 is an essential step towards achieving energy security, sustainability, and enhancing its position as
Share It

Political Unrest in Nepal

Nepal’s ongoing political unrest, exacerbated by Prime Minister K P Sharma Oli’s resignation and youth-led protests, has created a volatile environment that directly impacts India&rsqu
Share It

Karnataka Platform-Based Gig Workers

Karnataka has recently passed the Karnataka Platform-Based Gig Workers (Social Security and Welfare) Bill, 2025, aimed at safeguarding the rights and welfare of gig workers. Key Provisions of t
Share It

Income Tax Act 2025

The Income Tax Act, 2025 has received Presidential assent and will replace the Income Tax Act, 1961. The new Act is designed to simplify tax laws, modernize existing provisions, and improve the ef
Share It

Cotton Sector

The Union Government has taken significant steps to support the cotton sector in India, addressing key challenges related to rising imports, farmer welfare, and low domestic production. These meas
Share It

Aircraft Leasing: Wet and Dry Lease

In light of the ongoing global aircraft shortage exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic and supply chain disruptions, airlines have increasingly turned to wet and dry leases as solutions. These leas
Share It

India and Israel Sign New Bilateral Investment Treaty (BIT)

India and Israel have recently signed a Bilateral Investment Treaty (BIT), marking a significant development in their bilateral relationship. This agreement, which replaces the older BIT signed in
Share It

Newsletter Subscription


ACQ IAS
ACQ IAS