Daily News Analysis

Section 132 of the Income Tax Act, 1961

stylish_lining

Context: Despite the affirmation of the right to privacy in the 2017 Puttaswamy judgment, concerns persist regarding Section 132 of the Income Tax Act, potentially infringing on citizens' fundamental rights.

Understanding Section 132 of the Income Tax Act, 1961:

Introduction and Historical Context: Introduced to replace the invalidated Taxation on Income (Investigation Commission) Act, 1947, Section 132 had its roots in the Supreme Court's Suraj Mall Mohta vs A.V. Visvanatha Sastri (1954) ruling, declaring the old act discriminatory and in violation of Article 14 of the Constitution.

Empowering Tax Authorities: Section 132 grants tax authorities the power to conduct searches and seizures without a prior judicial warrant if there is a "reason to believe" that income has been concealed or evaded. This authority extends to searching buildings, places, vehicles, or aircraft based on suspicions of hiding financial assets, allowing for the seizure of relevant items during the search.

Challenges Associated with Section 132:

Breach of the Proportionality Principle: While not formally challenged, concerns arise about a potential breach of the proportionality principle. The use of search and seizure powers must align with legitimate aims, be rationally connected to objectives, lack alternative less intrusive means, and balance the means chosen with the violated right.

Violation of the Right to Privacy: Section 132 faces criticism for potentially infringing on the right to privacy, a fundamental right under Article 21, as income tax searches encroach on individuals' privacy without consent. Critics emphasize the need for stricter adherence to statutory law post-Puttaswamy and safeguards against potential misuse.

Duration and Conditions of Searches: Questions raised by the Gujarat High Court regarding the duration and conditions of searches highlight concerns. Instances of virtual detention without proper safeguards prompt a re-evaluation of the conditions and duration of searches under Section 132.

Proposed Solutions and the Way Forward:

Enhanced Judicial Review: Advocacy for an enhanced role of the judiciary in reviewing Section 132 applications, moving away from the Wednesbury principle, and adopting a more rigorous scrutiny standard to assess the proportionality of executive actions.

Independent Oversight Mechanism:Suggestion for establishing an independent oversight mechanism or ombudsman with the authority to investigate  complaints, ensure accountability, and recommend corrective measures in cases of potential misuse of powers.

Limiting Searches Duration and Conditions: Emphasis on the need to limit the duration and extent of income tax searches, addressing concerns about individuals being kept in virtual detention without proper safeguards.

Inclusivity of People with Disabilities in STEM Education

Current Situation: India has nearly 63 million people with disabilities (NFHS-5), but their representation in STEM fields is very low. Despite strong laws like the Right to Educat
Share It

National Handloom Day and the Swadeshi Movement

National Handloom Day Date: Celebrated every year on 7th August in India. Significance: Marks the launch of the Swadeshi Movement on 7 August 1905, which promoted indigenous indus
Share It

World Trade Organization (WTO)

Why in the News? India recently called for significant reforms at the World Trade Organization (WTO) during a high-level mini-ministerial meeting in Paris ahead of the 14th Ministerial Conferen
Share It

Israel-US-Iran Conflict

Recently, tensions in the Middle East escalated dramatically as Israel launched “Operation Rising Lion”, a significant military strike aimed at Iranian nuclear infrastructure and balli
Share It

Philippines President’s Visit to India (2025)

In 2025, during the Philippines President's state visit to India, both nations elevated their bilateral relationship to a Strategic Partnership. The visit reaffirmed the 1952 Treaty of Friends
Share It

India's Participation in the 51st G7 Summit

India participated as an Outreach Country in the 51st G7 Summit held in Kananaskis, Canada in 2025. Key Outcomes of the 51st G7 Summit (2025): Kananaskis Wildfire Charter:
Share It

Quit India Movement (QIM)

India commemorates 8th August every year as Quit India Movement Day (also known as August Kranti Diwas) to honor the historic movement that demanded the immediate end of British colonial rule in I
Share It

National Waterway-57 (Kopili River)

The National Waterway-57 (NW 57), running through the Kopili River in Assam, has been officially operationalised, marking a significant step in India’s development of Inland Water Transport
Share It

Union Cabinet Approves National Sports Policy (NSP) 2025

The Union Cabinet, chaired by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, has approved the National Sports Policy (NSP) 2025, aiming to address long-standing challenges and transform India into a global sportin
Share It

CIMMYT’s Financial Crisis

The International Maize and Wheat Improvement Center (CIMMYT), a pivotal institution in the development of agricultural research for maize, wheat, and related crops, is facing significant financia
Share It

Newsletter Subscription


ACQ IAS
ACQ IAS