Daily News Analysis

Higher judiciary suffers from Diversity-deficit

stylish_lining

Higher judiciary suffers from Diversity-deficit

Why in the news?

A Parliamentary committee report has reported that the higher judiciary suffers from diversity deficit as the representation of SCs, STs, OBCs, women and minorities are below the desired levels.

Observations of the Parliamentary Committee report:

        1. A declining trend has been observed in the representation of all marginalized sections of the Indian society.
        2. The representation of SCs, STs, OBCs, women and minorities are below the desired levels.
        3. The representation in the higher judiciary is not reflective of the social diversity of the country.

Representation in the Supreme Court:

  1. The first judge of Supreme Court from the Scheduled castes (SCs) and Other Backward Classes (OBCs) community were appointed only in 1980, 30 years after independence.
  2. The first women representation in the Supreme Court happened in 1989, 39 years since the existence of the Supreme Court.
  3. The Current strength of 35 judges in the Supreme Court consists of nearly 50% judges from the upper caste Hindus and disproportionate representation to other sections of the society – 3 women judges (the highest so far), 1 Muslim, 1 Christian, 1 Parsi and 1 Scheduled Caste judge have been appointed.
  4. There has been no judge from the Scheduled Tribe (ST) community appointed till date.

Lacunae in the Constitution:

Essential qualifications to be appointed as a judge of the Supreme court:

  1. A judge of one High Court or more (continuously), for at least five years, or
  2. An advocate there, for at least ten years, or
  3. A distinguished jurist, in the opinion of the President, is eligible to be recommended for appointment, a judge of the Supreme Court.

The criteria mentioned is based on the experience in law and age and remains silent on any other preferred eligibility criteria that leads to proportionate representation in the Judiciary.

Need for equal representation in the higher judiciary:

  1. To strengthen the trust, credibility and acceptability of the judiciary among its citizens.
  2. Institutional marginalization of the weaker sections of the society may lead to denial of the due rights of that particular community.
  3. Due representation of women in the judiciary shall act as a
    1. Hallmark of gender sensitive cases to be handled effectively
    2. Inclusion of different points of view
    3. Motivates women of the country to seek justice.

What has to be done?

  1. The Supreme Court and High Court collegium should recommend adequate number of candidates from the marginalized segments including women.
  2. Proper methodology has to be followed in the collegium to instill transparency and checks-and-balances in the appointment process.
  3. The problems of low women advocate in the country due to
    1. Patriarchal mindset and stigmatization of the role of advocates as a male-dominant profession,
    2. factors of age and familial responsibilities making the elevation of women judges from lower courts to high Courts and the Supreme Courts.
    3. No legislation seeking to mandate the representation of women judges.
    4. Vacancies can be used as an opportunity to include reservation.

Visakhapatnam Declaration on e-Governance

The Visakhapatnam Declaration on e-Governance marks a significant step in the development of digital governance in India, emphasizing inclusive, transparent, and citizen-centric practices. Adopted
Share It

Defamation in India

Recently, a Supreme Court judge raised concerns about the increasing misuse of defamation laws by political figures and private individuals to settle personal and political disputes. The judge sug
Share It

Simultaneous Elections

India's ongoing debate about simultaneous elections or the One Nation, One Election concept has gained momentum, with experts like Arvind Panagariya, Chairman of the 16th Finance Commission, e
Share It

Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) 2025 Summit

The 2025 SCO Heads of State Summit was held in Tianjin, China, marking a significant moment for the organization’s expanding role on the global stage. Key Highlights: Terrorism:
Share It

Production Gap Report 2025

The Production Gap Report 2025 reveals a troubling trend: many countries are planning to increase fossil fuel production well beyond the levels needed to limit global warming to 1.5°C as per t
Share It

India's Roadmap for Fusion Power

India's Institute for Plasma Research (IPR) in Gandhinagar has recently proposed a comprehensive roadmap for the development of fusion power, marking a significant leap towards harnessing fusi
Share It

Dhvani Missile

India's Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) is on the verge of a historic milestone with the upcoming test of Dhvani, a next-generation hypersonic missile that is set to prope
Share It

Global Innovation Index (GII) 2025

India has made remarkable strides in the field of innovation, moving up from 48th position in 2020 to 38th in 2025 among 139 global economies, according to the World Intellectual Property Organiza
Share It

Critical Minerals

India’s first auction of deep-sea blocks for the extraction of critical minerals has been delayed indefinitely after receiving a poor response from bidders. This auction was expected to be a
Share It

CAG Report on States’ Fiscal Health

The Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG) has released its first decadal analysis on the fiscal health of 28 Indian states, revealing significant concerns over the increasing public debt.
Share It

Newsletter Subscription


ACQ IAS
ACQ IAS