Daily News Analysis

Global dispute settlement, India and appellate review

stylish_lining

Global dispute settlement, India and appellate review

 

 

Why in the News?

The New Delhi Leaders Declaration at G20 reiterated the need to pursue reform of the WTO “to ensure a fully and well-functioning dispute settlement system accessible to all members by 2024”.

Issues with World Trade Organization (WTO):

  1. The dispute settlement system, a two-tier panel cum appellate body structure, has been dysfunctional since 2019 as the United States has blocked the appointment of appellate body members.
    1. The dispute settlement system has issued over 493 rulings since its establishment in 1995 (the International Court of Justice has dealt with only around 190 cases since 1947).
    2. The appellate body of WTO has been crucial in ensuring coherence and predictability in rulings and confidence in the WTO dispute settlement process.
  2. U. S’s continued opposition to an appellate review process seems to be inclined towards the de-judicialization of international trade law.
    1. This can allow countries to take back control from international courts and tribunals.
    2. The appellate review process at the international level serves as an essential check on the interpretation and application of law and ensures consistency.

Benefits of an appellate review:

  1. Inconsistent and incoherent decisions and legal reasoning.
    1. For instance, the Investor-state-dispute settlement (ISDS), an international investment law of Bilateral Investment Treaties (BITs) operates through ad hoc or one-off arbitration tribunals without any appellate review.
    2. The ISDS tribunals operating under different arbitral institutions have offered diverging interpretations of the same treaty provision and even reached opposite conclusions despite interpreting and applying the same treaty to the same facts.
    3. This has caused instability and improbability for states and foreign investors.
  2. An appellate review shall allow for rectifying errors of law and harmonising diverging interpretations.
  3. It shall have the power to uphold, modify, or reverse the decision of a first-tier tribunal and thus bringing coherence and consistency, and hence predictability and certainty into the ISDS system. 

 Critical issues in creating an appellate review:

  1. The form in which the appellate mechanism shall take place
    1. Ad hoc appellate mechanism, where a body will be constituted by the disputing parties on a case-by-case basis, or
    2. a standing appellate mechanism
  2. Deciding on the standard to review the decisions of the first-tier tribunal.
  3. Finalising the time frame and the effect of the decision rendered by the appellate review.

India’s stand:

  1. India, presumably, supports the idea of an appellate review in the ISDS because Article 29 of the Indian model BIT advocates it. 
  2. Supporting the creation of an appellate review mechanism will be in India’s interest as it will address the concerns about inconsistency and incoherence in the ISDS system.
  3. Since India’s quest is to establish a rule-based global order, support to an appellate review shall usher in greater confidence for states and investors in international investment law.

India-UK Vision 2035

The Indian Prime Minister's visit to London was indeed a significant diplomatic milestone, as it unveiled the India–UK Vision 2035 roadmap and formalized the Comprehensive Economic and T
Share It

Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989

The Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 is a critical piece of legislation designed to protect the rights and dignity of Scheduled Castes (SCs) and Scheduled
Share It

Financial Inclusion Index

The Financial Inclusion Index (FI-Index), as reported by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), is a key metric that measures the level of financial inclusion across the country. Overview of the Fin
Share It

International Seabed Authority

The International Seabed Authority (ISA) is currently in the midst of negotiations regarding the extraction of metals from the high seas, particularly as U.S. efforts to fast-track this practice h
Share It

Election of Vice-President of India

Article 64 of the Constitution of India specifies that the Vice-President's post cannot remain vacant for any period of time, as it is essential for the functioning of the Rajya Sabha (Council
Share It

Maharashtra Scraps Hindi as Compulsory Third Language

The Maharashtra government recently scrapped its Government Resolutions (GRs) that mandated Hindi as a compulsory third language from Grades 1 to 5 in Marathi and English medium schools. While the
Share It

River Pollution in India

The Delhi government's focus on cleaning up the Yamuna River is part of a larger national effort to rejuvenate the Ganga River and its tributaries, in alignment with the Namami Gange Programme
Share It

Infrastructure Failures

The recent collapse of the Mahisagar River Bridge in Vadodara, which tragically claimed the lives of 20 people, underscores the growing concern over India's infrastructure quality. Similar
Share It

Special Intensive Revision (SIR)

The Supreme Court (SC) is currently reviewing the Election Commission of India’s (ECI) process for the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in Bihar, suggesting that Aadhaar,
Share It

GM Crop

In ongoing trade talks, the United States is advocating for India to open its agriculture market to genetically modified (GM) crops. However, India has firmly rejected this proposal, citing concer
Share It

Newsletter Subscription


ACQ IAS
ACQ IAS