Daily News Analysis

Balancing Public Safety and Animal Welfare

stylish_lining

The Supreme Court of India has recently issued a suo motu directive to remove stray dogs from the National Capital Region (NCR) following tragic attacks on children. This move has ignited a critical debate on how to balance the imperative of public safety with the ethical and legal responsibilities towards animal welfare.

The Menace of Stray Dogs in India

India faces a serious challenge with an estimated 62 to 80 million stray dogs nationwide. In 2024 alone, over 2.2 million dog bite cases were reported. Rabies transmitted through these bites accounts for 36% of global rabies deaths, disproportionately affecting vulnerable groups such as children, women, and the elderly. According to the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB), more than 4,000 fatalities due to dog bites occurred in 2019. Delhi alone recorded over 35,000 animal bite incidents in the first half of 2025, posing a considerable public health risk. Furthermore, the financial burden on healthcare systems is significant, with an average cost of Rs 5,128 per case for rabies treatment.

Legal and Policy Frameworks Governing Stray Dogs

India’s legal framework reflects a complex governance structure concerning stray dog management:

  • Constitutional Provisions:

    • Article 246(3) assigns states the responsibility for animal health and veterinary practices.

    • Articles 243(W) and 246 empower local bodies to control stray dog populations.

    • Article 51A(g) imposes a fundamental duty on citizens to show compassion towards all living beings.

    • Article 21’s scope, as expanded by the Supreme Court in Animal Welfare Board of India v. Nagaraja (2014), extends the right to life to animals, reaffirming their legal protection.

  • Legal Statutes and Policies:

    • The Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960, prohibits animal cruelty and mandates humane treatment.

    • The Animal Birth Control (ABC) Rules, 2023, mandate sterilization, vaccination, and release of stray dogs back to their habitats.

    • The National Rabies Control Program (NRCP), spearheaded by the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, aims to eliminate rabies by 2030 via vaccination, sterilization, and rigorous surveillance.

Ethical Dimensions of Stray Dog Management

The increasing incidence of dog bites and rabies fatalities has created a moral dilemma between protecting human life and upholding animal rights:

  • Human Safety vs. Animal Rights:
    Aggressive stray dogs pose a significant threat to public safety, especially vulnerable children. However, prioritizing animal welfare under the ABC Rules sometimes risks compromising human rights under Article 21, particularly when aggressive dogs are released back into the community.

  • Disparities and Ethical Dilemmas:
    Society often accords pet dogs affection and status, while stray dogs are marginalized, raising concerns about unequal treatment. Methods such as culling, poisoning, or forced relocation violate ethical principles of compassion and humane treatment.

  • Corruption and Program Inefficiencies:
    Mismanagement of funds intended for sterilization and vaccination hampers the effectiveness of welfare programs, compromising both ethical obligations and public safety goals.

Ethical Frameworks Guiding Management Strategies

  • Utilitarian Ethics promote sterilization and vaccination as measures that maximize overall welfare by reducing rabies risk and population growth while avoiding cruelty.

  • Deontological Ethics emphasize society’s duty to protect both citizens and animals.

  • Rights-Based Ethics view stray dogs as possessing inherent rights requiring protection and humane care.

  • Cultural Ethos of Ahimsa underscores India’s tradition of compassion and coexistence with all living beings.

  • The One Health Approach integrates animal welfare with human and environmental health, promoting ethical stewardship across sectors.

Best Practices from India and Abroad

  • Bengaluru’s ABC program demonstrated a 10% reduction in stray dog populations and a 20% increase in neutering rates between 2019 and 2023.

  • The Netherlands achieved a “stray dog-free” status through its Collect-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return (CNVR) program, coupled with adoption drives.

  • Istanbul runs a successful Trap-Neuter-Vaccinate-Return (TNVR) program with sterilized dogs tagged and community feeders engaged, stabilizing populations and nearly eliminating rabies.

  • Bangkok replaced mass culling with TNVR, significantly reducing rabies outbreaks and community aggression.

Measures to Balance Public Safety with Animal Welfare

  • Leveraging Dogs’ Cognitive Abilities: Harness dogs’ roles in drug detection, bomb sniffing, and therapy to promote positive societal views.

  • Collaborative Policy Implementation: Governments must partner with civil society to expand vaccination and sterilization efforts, prevent pet abandonment, and frame a national policy addressing human-dog conflicts.

  • Dedicated Infrastructure: Establish feeding stations, veterinary healthcare facilities, and support animal welfare organizations. Implement a helpline for reporting attacks.

  • Public Awareness and Education: Campaigns on responsible pet ownership, sterilization benefits, and safe human-animal interactions are vital to reduce dog bites and abandonment.

Conclusion

The Supreme Court’s directive highlights the urgent need to reconcile public safety concerns with ethical obligations toward animal welfare. By fostering compassion, adopting humane and science-based policies, and engaging citizens through education and cooperation, India can pave the way for peaceful coexistence where the rights and safety of both humans and animals are respected.

 

 

Visakhapatnam Declaration on e-Governance

The Visakhapatnam Declaration on e-Governance marks a significant step in the development of digital governance in India, emphasizing inclusive, transparent, and citizen-centric practices. Adopted
Share It

Defamation in India

Recently, a Supreme Court judge raised concerns about the increasing misuse of defamation laws by political figures and private individuals to settle personal and political disputes. The judge sug
Share It

Simultaneous Elections

India's ongoing debate about simultaneous elections or the One Nation, One Election concept has gained momentum, with experts like Arvind Panagariya, Chairman of the 16th Finance Commission, e
Share It

Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) 2025 Summit

The 2025 SCO Heads of State Summit was held in Tianjin, China, marking a significant moment for the organization’s expanding role on the global stage. Key Highlights: Terrorism:
Share It

Production Gap Report 2025

The Production Gap Report 2025 reveals a troubling trend: many countries are planning to increase fossil fuel production well beyond the levels needed to limit global warming to 1.5°C as per t
Share It

India's Roadmap for Fusion Power

India's Institute for Plasma Research (IPR) in Gandhinagar has recently proposed a comprehensive roadmap for the development of fusion power, marking a significant leap towards harnessing fusi
Share It

Dhvani Missile

India's Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) is on the verge of a historic milestone with the upcoming test of Dhvani, a next-generation hypersonic missile that is set to prope
Share It

Global Innovation Index (GII) 2025

India has made remarkable strides in the field of innovation, moving up from 48th position in 2020 to 38th in 2025 among 139 global economies, according to the World Intellectual Property Organiza
Share It

Critical Minerals

India’s first auction of deep-sea blocks for the extraction of critical minerals has been delayed indefinitely after receiving a poor response from bidders. This auction was expected to be a
Share It

CAG Report on States’ Fiscal Health

The Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG) has released its first decadal analysis on the fiscal health of 28 Indian states, revealing significant concerns over the increasing public debt.
Share It

Newsletter Subscription


ACQ IAS
ACQ IAS