Daily News Analysis

Topic: Abrogation of Article 370

stylish_lining

Why in news?

The Supreme Court is set to test the constitutionality of repeal of Article 340 in 2018.

What is Article 370?

  1. Jammu & Kashmir (J&K), a princely state during British rule, wanted to remain as an independent state post-independence.
  2. But, Raja Hari Singh, the ruler of J&K had to sign the Instrument of Accession with India following Pakistan's invasion against it on Oct 26, 1947.
  3. A Special status for J&K was negotiated by its first Prime minister Sheikh Abdulla in the constituent assembly.
  4. Article 370 was introduced as a temporary provision that conferred special status to J&K
    • Only those aspects of the Indian Constitution agreed upon in the Instrument of Accession shall be applicable to J&K.
    • Laws can be made applicable to J&K only by the President with the consultation of the State government in the matters of Defence, Foreign affairs and communication. Thereby, it restricted the power of the Parliament.
    • For application of other articles of the constitution presidential order with concurrence of the state government is mandatory.
    • Using the special provisions a constituent assembly drafted and adopted the Constitution exclusively for J&K.
    • Article 35A
    • Was introduced under article 370 through a presidential order in 1954
    •  It defined the states' Permanent residents, their special rights and privileges.
    • Permanent residents were defined as people who were a state subject as of May 14, 1954 or a resident of the state for 10 years any time since.
    • Permanent residents alone could buy and own property in the state.
  5. Abrogation of Article 370  - 2 Presidential Orders
    • a. First Presidential order - To neutralize the Fail-safe mechanism inherent in Article 370(3) that specifies mandatory president's concurrence with Constituent assembly of the state to amend/ revoke a provision. The order made following changes,
      • New Interpretation clause- The Governor of J&K shall deem to act on behalf the elected representatives of the state for time being. At that time, the state was under President's rule.
      • 'Constituent assembly of the state' was substituted with the expression 'Legislative assembly of the state'.
    • b. Second Presidential order
      • Made the entire constitution of India applicable to J&K by taking Governor's concurrence.
      • The order superseded the Constitution (Application to Jammu & Kashmir) Order, 1954 which defined the constitutional position between J&K with Indian Union
    • C. The state was broken into two Union Territories (UTs) of J&K and Ladakh with the former having a legislative assembly.
      • By passing J&K Reorganisation Act, 2019
      • Now Parliament became their legislatives due to their UT Tag.
      • Later, Delimitation exercise was carried out by making the Delimitation Act, 2022 applicable to J&K

On what grounds the repeal of Art 370 has been challenged in the court?

  • Making permanent changes to the state under the President's rule is against the constitutional ethos.
  • Taking Governor's consent to nullify Art 370 is akin to Centre taking its own consent. It is against the Federal spirit of the Constitution.
  • Art 370 can be modified only on recommendation of J&K Constituent assembly and it is not subject to amendment powers of the constitution.

Downside of the abrogation:

  • Huge trust deficit as governmental policies are looked upon with suspicion as hidden agenda.
    • For instance, Anti-encroachment drive, policy allowing outsiders to buy land in J&K, the delimitation exercise is seen as an attempt to change the demography of J&K.

The upside of the move:

  • Militancy has been on decline, with only 4 encounters in Kashmir in this year so far.
  • Tourism is in the boom phase: All time high of 2.3million visitors in 2022
  • Integrated development through Industries- New Industrial policy post 370 abrogation has drawn investment worth Rs.60000 crore, fourfold compared to the last 70 years in J&K.

Critical Minerals

India’s first auction of deep-sea blocks for the extraction of critical minerals has been delayed indefinitely after receiving a poor response from bidders. This auction was expected to be a
Share It

CAG Report on States’ Fiscal Health

The Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG) has released its first decadal analysis on the fiscal health of 28 Indian states, revealing significant concerns over the increasing public debt.
Share It

President's Rule

The extension of President’s Rule in Manipur has brought to the fore the historical and controversial use of Article 356 of the Indian Constitution, shedding light on how its imposition disr
Share It

Beggars' Homes in India

In M.S. Patter v. State of NCT of Delhi, the Supreme Court (SC) held that state-run beggars’ homes are not merely penal institutions or charitable endeavors but are instead constitutional tr
Share It

Public Distribution System (PDS)

India's Public Distribution System (PDS) has long been a cornerstone of food security, ensuring access to subsidised cereals for millions of people. However, a recent Crisil study using the &l
Share It

Saudi-Pakistan Strategic Mutual Defense Agreement (SMDA)

The recent Saudi-Pakistan Strategic Mutual Defense Agreement (SMDA) represents a major shift in the geopolitical landscape of the Middle East and South Asia, with significant implications for Indi
Share It

Wassenaar Arrangement

The Wassenaar Arrangement is facing significant challenges in adapting its controls to the rapid growth of cloud technology. This issue highlights the need to update its control lists and enforcem
Share It

National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB)

The National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) report for 2023 highlights a 9.2% increase in crimes against children in India, with 177,335 cases registered in total. This reflects a concerning rise in
Share It

Doctrine of Contributory Negligence

The Andhra Pradesh High Court recently made an important ruling regarding the doctrine of contributory negligence in criminal law. The court clarified that contributory negligence does not apply t
Share It

Perpetual Bonds

The Indian Renewable Energy Development Agency Ltd (IREDA) recently raised ₹453 crore at an interest rate of 7.70% per annum through its second issue of Perpetual Bonds. This move is part of the
Share It

Newsletter Subscription


ACQ IAS
ACQ IAS