Daily News Analysis

Rethink the emerging dynamics of India’s fiscal federalism

stylish_lining

Rethink the emerging dynamics of India’s fiscal federalism

 

 

Indian Federalism:

  1. A ‘holding together federation’ with a built-in unitary bias.
  2. Dual Polity: Separate independent Govts at Centre & States.
  3. Written Constitution: Powers of Centre & States clearly marked out in the form a written book.
  4. Division of Powers: Powers divided into Union (100 subjects), State (61 subjects) & Concurrent (52 subjects) Lists.
  5. Supremacy of Constitution: All organs of Govt at Centre & States operate within jurisdiction provided by Const. Centre can’t step over States.
  6. Rigid Constitution: Provisions regarding Federal Structure of Country are difficult to amend, requiring Special Majority + Consent of States.
  7. Independent Judiciary: To protect & enforce Supremacy of Constitution.
  8. Bicameralism: Rajya Sabha is a permanent representation of States.
  9. Federal System was adopted due to the large size of the Country & Socio-cultural diversity.

Recent changes in the Federal-Fiscal landscape:

  1. Paradigm shift from a planned economy to a market-mediated economic system
  2. The transformation of a two-tier federation into a multi-tier fiscal system following the 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendments
  3. Abolition of the Planning Commission and its replacement with NITI Aayog
  4. Passing of the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management (FRBM) Act
  5. Goods and Services (GST) Act with the GST.
  6. The extensive use of cess and surcharges which affect the size of the divisible pool.

Issues with India’s Fiscal federalism:

  1. India’s intergovernmental transfer system is failing on the aspect of ‘equity-orientation’.
    • The top 1% earners in India captured less than 21% of the total income in the 1930s which dipped to 6% in the early 1980s, but rose to 22% during the liberalisation era.
    • The tax exemptions, tax concessions and other revenues forgone has disproportionately favoured the rich and have reduced the size of the divisible pool.
  2. Several pieces of central legislation have imposed extra burden on the States.
    • For instance, central acts such as Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA), 2005, The Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act 2009, the National Food Security Act 2013.
  3. The functional and financial responsibilities of the Panchayat Raj Institutions and municipalities has not been clearly demarcated with the passing of 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendments.
  4. The absence of a uniform financial reporting system comprising all levels of government, placing the third tier properly on the fiscal federal map of India is a major deficit.
    • Though the Constitution refers to the third tier as ‘institutions of self-government’ policymakers, experts have referred to it has ‘local bodies.’

What has to be done?

  1. ‘Equity-oriented’ intergovernmental transfer system should be the norm.
    • Equity should be the main concern of the 16th Finance Commission.
    • HDI can be used as a strong candidate in the horizontal distribution of tax devolution.
    • Article 246 and the Seventh Schedule has to be revisited regarding division of powers, functions and responsibilities for a variety of reasons.
  2. A new local list which specifies the functional and financial responsibilities of the Panchayat Raj Institutions and municipalities has to be carried out.
  3. The third tier of government has to be properly placed on the fiscal federal map of India by devising uniform financial reporting system that includes,
    • Standard budgeting rules for all tiers
    • Introduction of the accrual-based accounting system.
  4. Need to review the off-Budget borrowing practices of both the Union and the States, as they are unscrutinised and unreported. All extra-budgetary transactions have to be brought to the public domain.
    • It is a Universal norm that all income and expenditure transactions should fall under some Budget head or the other.
    • State public sector undertakings and special purpose vehicles raise resources from the markets, but their servicing burden often falls on the State government.
    • In many cases the government being the ultimate guarantor, the burden of repaying the debt also falls on the State.
    • States are disciplined through Article 293(3) by the Union through the FRBM Act, the Union often escapes such controls.
    • The National Small Saving Fund (NSSF) has been liberally utilised for extra-budgetary financing of central public sector undertakings and central ministries by way of loans which is not reflected in the Union fiscal deficits.
    • The borrowing space of States is restricted, the Union escapes such discipline.

MCQ:

Which among the following is not a federal feature of the Indian Constitution?

  1. Integrated judiciary
  2. Office of the Governor
  3. Written Constitution
  4. Bicameralism
  5. Emergency provisions
  6. Supremacy of the Constitution

How many among the given options is correct?

  1. Only 2
  2. Only 3
  3. Only 4
  4. Only 5

Ans: b)

Explanation:

All of the below are unitary features of the constitution and not federal features.

  1. Integrated judiciary
  2. Office of the Governor
  3. Emergency provisions

Other unitary features include:

  1. Strong Centre
  2. Indestructible Union with destructible states
  3. Single Constitution
  4. Flexibility of the Constitution
  5. Single Citizenship
  6. All-India Services 
  7. Integrated Audit Machinery
  8. Parliament’s Authority over State Lists on passage of resolution by the Rajya Sabha
  9. Integrated Election Machinery
  10. Veto over State Bills 

 

India-UK Vision 2035

The Indian Prime Minister's visit to London was indeed a significant diplomatic milestone, as it unveiled the India–UK Vision 2035 roadmap and formalized the Comprehensive Economic and T
Share It

Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989

The Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 is a critical piece of legislation designed to protect the rights and dignity of Scheduled Castes (SCs) and Scheduled
Share It

Financial Inclusion Index

The Financial Inclusion Index (FI-Index), as reported by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), is a key metric that measures the level of financial inclusion across the country. Overview of the Fin
Share It

International Seabed Authority

The International Seabed Authority (ISA) is currently in the midst of negotiations regarding the extraction of metals from the high seas, particularly as U.S. efforts to fast-track this practice h
Share It

Election of Vice-President of India

Article 64 of the Constitution of India specifies that the Vice-President's post cannot remain vacant for any period of time, as it is essential for the functioning of the Rajya Sabha (Council
Share It

Maharashtra Scraps Hindi as Compulsory Third Language

The Maharashtra government recently scrapped its Government Resolutions (GRs) that mandated Hindi as a compulsory third language from Grades 1 to 5 in Marathi and English medium schools. While the
Share It

River Pollution in India

The Delhi government's focus on cleaning up the Yamuna River is part of a larger national effort to rejuvenate the Ganga River and its tributaries, in alignment with the Namami Gange Programme
Share It

Infrastructure Failures

The recent collapse of the Mahisagar River Bridge in Vadodara, which tragically claimed the lives of 20 people, underscores the growing concern over India's infrastructure quality. Similar
Share It

Special Intensive Revision (SIR)

The Supreme Court (SC) is currently reviewing the Election Commission of India’s (ECI) process for the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in Bihar, suggesting that Aadhaar,
Share It

GM Crop

In ongoing trade talks, the United States is advocating for India to open its agriculture market to genetically modified (GM) crops. However, India has firmly rejected this proposal, citing concer
Share It

Newsletter Subscription


ACQ IAS
ACQ IAS