Daily News Analysis

One off-key conduct by in-laws cannot be called cruelty under Section 498A: Supreme Court

stylish_lining

Context: The apex court was hearing the appeal of a woman who was accused by her newly-wed sister-in-law of using foul language and dumping the latter’s belongings in the dustbin

The Issue: The Supreme Court of India ruled that a single instance of bad behavior, including using foul language and disposing of another's belongings, does not amount to "cruelty" under Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) related to dowry harassment.

The Verdict: The court quashed the criminal proceedings against a woman accused by her sister-in-law of such behavior due to:

  • Lack of material evidence beyond the single incident.
  • Accused not living with the complainant, residing abroad.
  • Complainant's vague and general accusations.
  • Previous divorce of the complainant from the accused's brother.

Solutions:

  • Focus on pattern of behavior: Instead of relying on isolated incidents, courts should consider a pattern of repeated abusive behavior towards the wife by the husband or his relatives.
  • Strengthen evidence requirements: More concrete evidence beyond verbal claims should be required to substantiate accusations of cruelty under Section 498A.
  • Promote mediation and counseling: Encourage family mediation and counseling before resorting to legal action to address marital discord and potential for reconciliation.
  • Reform Section 498A: Consider potential amendments to the law to clarify and refine the definition of "cruelty" and protect against misuse of the Section.
  • Overall, the ruling emphasizes the need for careful evaluation of evidence and consideration of context before applying the strict penalties associated with Section 498A. Implementing the proposed solutions can help ensure its effective application in genuine cases of dowry harassment while minimizing misinterpretations and misuse.

Section 498A of IPC

  • Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code 1860 was passed by the Indian Parliament in 1983.
  • The section of 498A of the Indian Penal Code is a criminal law.
  • It is defined that if the husband or the relative of the husband of a woman, subjected such woman towards cruelty would be punished with imprisonment for a term which might extend to 3 years and may also be liable for fine.
  • Section 498 A of Indian Penal Code is one of the greatest rescues for Violence against Woman (VAW), which is a reflection of the pathetic reality of the domestic violence occurring within the four walls of a house.

 

Global South

Prime Minister Narendra Modi's visit to Brazil from July 2-9, 2025, for the BRICS summit, was not only his longest international visit in 11 years but also marked a significant diplomatic outr
Share It

Maharashtra’s Special Public Security Bill, 2024

The Maharashtra Assembly has recently passed the Special Public Security Bill, 2024, aimed at combating “urban Maoism” and left-wing extremism in the state. The Bill criminalizes activ
Share It

Human Trafficking Networks and the 'Donkey Route'

The Enforcement Directorate (ED) and the National Investigation Agency (NIA) have launched aggressive probes into illegal human trafficking networks operating through the infamous "Donkey Rou
Share It

Patriot Air Defence Missile System (MIM-104)

Patriot Systems in Ukraine -The recent decision by the United States to send Patriot air defense systems to Ukraine amid growing Russian aggression underscores the system's strategic importanc
Share It

Flue Gas Desulphurisation (FGD) Systems

Recently, the Indian Environment Ministry has made a significant policy change by exempting most coal-fired power plants in the country from the mandatory installation of Flue Gas Desulphurisation
Share It

Misclassification of India’s Open Ecosystems

India’s deserts, grasslands, and savannas are collectively referred to as open ecosystems they are ecologically rich and culturally significant landscapes. However, these areas have been mis
Share It

Aircraft Accident Investigation in India

The crash of Air India AI 171 in Ahmedabad, which led to the tragic death of 241 passengers and crew members, has raised serious concerns. The Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB), tasked
Share It

Ordinarily Resident Status

The Special Intensive Revision (SIR) in Bihar, initiated by the Election Commission of India (ECI), has raised important discussions about electoral inclusion and migrant populations. Who is an &l
Share It

Zonal Councils

The Union Home Minister recently remarked that Zonal Councils have transformed from being mere discussion forums into engines of cooperation, with 83% of the issues discussed in these meetings bei
Share It

BRICS Grouping

Recently, U.S. President Donald Trump threatened to impose 10% tariffs on members of the BRICS grouping, including Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa.. Implications of U.S. Tariff T
Share It

Newsletter Subscription


ACQ IAS
ACQ IAS