Daily News Analysis

Demand for Holding Parliament Sessions Outside Delhi:

stylish_lining

Demand for Holding Parliament Sessions Outside Delhi:

Why in News?

Recently, a Member of Parliament (MP) from the YSR Congress proposed the idea of holding two sessions of the Indian Parliament each year in South India. The proposal highlights logistical and climatic challenges that MPs face due to the extreme winters and scorching summers in Delhi. This suggestion has historical support from leaders such as Dr. B.R. Ambedkar and Atal Bihari Vajpayee, who had also advocated for decentralizing the location of parliamentary sessions.

Previous Demands for Holding Parliamentary Sessions Outside Delhi

  1. Dr. B.R. Ambedkar's Vision: Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, in his book “Thoughts on Linguistic States”, suggested decentralizing the capital and holding parliamentary sessions outside Delhi. He argued that Delhi was inconvenient for people from the southern states due to its extreme climate and geographical distance, which made southerners feel politically alienated. Ambedkar also pointed out Delhi’s vulnerability to attacks, being within the bombing range of neighboring countries. He proposed Hyderabad as a potential second capital for India, especially for summer months, due to its central location and relatively milder climate.

  2. Prakash Vir Shastri's Resolution (1959): In November 1959, Independent MP Prakash Vir Shastri introduced a Private Member’s Resolution proposing that the Lok Sabha hold a session in South India, with Hyderabad or Bangalore suggested as possible locations. This proposal was backed by Atal Bihari Vajpayee, then a first-time MP, who supported the idea of strengthening national unity through such a decentralizing initiative.

Constitutional Status of Holding Parliament Sessions

  • The Constitution of India does not specify a fixed location for holding parliamentary sessions.

  • Article 85 of the Indian Constitution empowers the President to summon each House of Parliament at such times and places as deemed fit, ensuring that no more than six months elapse between two sessions.

  • Although the Constitution allows flexibility in choosing the location, New Delhi has traditionally been the seat of Parliament since independence.

Arguments for Holding Parliament Sessions Outside Delhi

  1. Enhanced Regional Representation:

    • Holding parliamentary sessions in southern cities could increase the visibility of southern states in national policymaking. It would send a strong message of inclusivity and reflect a commitment to giving every region a voice in the legislative process.

  2. Climate Considerations:

    • The extreme weather conditions in Delhi, such as severe cold in winters and intense heat in summers, can impede the effective functioning of MPs. Moving sessions to more temperate regions could enhance the health and productivity of legislators, thus improving the overall efficiency of governance.

  3. Decentralization of Power:

    • The move could align with the principle of decentralizing political power. Decentralization can help make governance more accessible to people across the country, ensuring that all citizens feel equally represented, irrespective of their geographical location.

  4. Historical Precedent:

    • The backing of prominent figures like Dr. B.R. Ambedkar and Atal Bihari Vajpayee for the decentralization idea provides credibility to the argument. Their support suggests that this is not a new or politically motivated idea but one rooted in long-standing concerns about regional balance and national unity.

Challenges of Shifting Parliamentary Sessions Outside Delhi

  1. Logistical Hurdles:

    • Relocating the parliamentary machinery, infrastructure, and personnel to another region would be complex and resource-intensive. It could also disrupt the smooth functioning of Parliament and entail significant costs for transportation, accommodation, and other logistics.

  2. Political Polarization:

    • Critics argue that holding sessions in different parts of the country may deepen the existing North-South divide, emphasizing regional identities over national unity. There are concerns that such a move could fuel regionalism and make governance more fragmented.

  3. Institutional History:

    • Parliament has operated out of Delhi for over 75 years without adversely impacting the integration of southern states into the Union. Critics believe that the current system of conducting parliamentary sessions in New Delhi is well-established and that alternative mechanisms, such as more frequent consultations and regional representation, should be explored instead.

Countries with Multiple Capitals

Several countries have decentralized capitals for various functions, which might offer lessons for India:

  1. South Africa:

    • South Africa has three capitals: Pretoria (administrative), Cape Town (legislative), and Bloemfontein (judicial). This decentralization ensures that power is spread across the country, promoting regional representation.

  2. Malaysia:

    • Kuala Lumpur is the administrative capital, while Putrajaya serves as the administrative and judicial hub. The development of Putrajaya has alleviated congestion in Kuala Lumpur and provided a more organized setting for government functions.

  3. Switzerland:

    • Bern is the federal city, but the country maintains a decentralized political structure, balancing the interests of its diverse linguistic and cultural groups.

  4. Australia:

    • Canberra was purpose-built as the country’s capital, located strategically between Sydney and Melbourne, ensuring neutrality and unity between the two largest cities.

Way Forward

  1. Pilot Regional Sessions:

    • Conducting occasional parliamentary committee meetings or winter sessions in southern cities like Bengaluru or Hyderabad can help assess logistical challenges and public response. This gradual approach could pave the way for more frequent sessions held outside Delhi.

  2. Strengthening Regional Representation:

    • Addressing underrepresentation through increased parliamentary seats for southern states after the next census reforms could balance regional equity without disrupting existing systems.

  3. Investing in Technology and Logistics:

    • Improving communication technology and streamlining logistics can help reduce the challenges related to travel and climate, ensuring that MPs from all regions can participate in parliamentary proceedings with ease.

Conclusion

The proposal to hold parliamentary sessions in South India raises important questions about regional representation, inclusivity, and governance. While it highlights legitimate concerns about climate and accessibility, its feasibility is debated. A balanced approach—conducting pilot sessions in different regions, strengthening existing mechanisms for regional representation, and leveraging technology for smoother integration—could ensure that the goal of decentralization is achieved without compromising parliamentary efficiency. This debate presents an opportunity to rethink India's governance structures for greater inclusivity and resilience.


 

India’s Import Curbs on Jute Products from Bangladesh

India has imposed immediate restrictions on the import of jute and allied fibre products from Bangladesh. These apply at all Indian land and seaports except Nhava Sheva in Maharash
Share It

GPS Interference

  GPS interference refers to deliberate or unintentional disruption of Global Positioning System (GPS) signals, which are crucial for navigation in aircraft, ships, and ground transport sy
Share It

India’s Civil Nuclear Law Reform:

  India is revising its civil nuclear laws—the Atomic Energy Act (AEA), 1962 and the Civil Liability for Nuclear Damage Act (CLNDA), 2010—to: Attract private and forei
Share It

Secondary Pollutants

A recent study has shed light on an important aspect of India's air pollution crisis: secondary pollutants, which now contribute to nearly one-third of PM2.5 pollution in the country. These pollut
Share It

Myogenesis

Group Captain Shubhanshu Shukla’s Myogenesis experiments on the ISS represent a major leap forward in India’s space research efforts, focusing on the formation and regulation of muscle fib
Share It

Central Sector Scheme of Scholarship for College and University Students (CSSS)

A scholarship scheme under the Pradhan Mantri Uchchatar Shiksha Protsahan (PM-USP) initiative by the Ministry of Education’s Department of Higher Education. It Provides financial assistance to m
Share It

Khasi People

The Meghalaya High Court has admitted a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) concerning the tribal certificate issuance for the Khasi community.This PIL challenges a government decision that has halted th
Share It

Similipal Tiger Reserve

Odisha High Court issued a notice to the Integrated Tribal Development Agency (ITDA) over a ban on Munda tribals from accessing Jayara, a sacred grove inside the tiger reserve.This raised concerns ove
Share It

Begonia nyishiorum

A fascinating new species of flowering plant, Begonia nyishiorum, has been discovered in the East Kameng district of Arunachal Pradesh, further highlighting the rich but underexplored biodiversity of
Share It

Asiatic Wild Dog

Asiatic Wild Dog A new study by the Wildlife Institute of India (WII) has confirmed the return of the dhole (Asiatic wild dog) to Kaziranga-Karbi Anglong Landscape (KKAL) in Assam, after being beli
Share It

Newsletter Subscription


ACQ IAS
ACQ IAS