Daily News Analysis

DEMOLISHING THE FRAME FROM OUTSIDE THE CONSTITUTION

stylish_lining

Why in the News?

The Delhi Police arrested two persons of news portal NewsClick by invoking the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act on the charges of

  • Accessing funds from pro-China elements 
  • Coverage of events such as the farmers’ protests in 2020-21, that undermined the internal security of India.

The line set by “basic structure doctrine” has been crossed:

  1. The doctrine was established by the Supreme Court to restrict majoritarianism over fundamental rights.
  2. Recent developments relating to religious minorities, freedom of expression and speech and political financing reflects that the line has been crossed by subverting it from outside the text of the constitution.
  3. Though Court is an unelected institution in a system that has an elected legislature, its legitimacy in striking down laws lies in its act of protecting the democratic process.
    1. The representative body is best to decide on what rules and values should govern a society.
    2. However, the courts have obligation to protect the integrity of the process of democracy, as a faulty democratic process can raise questions over the legitimacy of the representative body itself.
  4. Indian judiciary has more powers than just protecting the integrity of the democratic process. Those include:
    1. strike down laws and constitutional amendments.
    2. Can imply restriction on Parliament in amending the Constitution through the basic structure doctrine.
  5. In spite of the active roles played by the Judiciary to retain the text of the constitution, it can be diminished from the outside.

Democracy undermined:

  1. The constitutional part of “constitutional democracy” says that democracy is not just in the principle of majority decision-making but decisions made in democratic conditions.
  2. Such democratic conditions shall include, “whose structure, composition, and practices treat all members of the community, as individuals, with equal respect and concern”.
  3. Such “democratic conditions” can be attainable only by adopting basic values that contribute to a robust democracy, such as
    1. freedom of speech and expression
    2. freedom of association.
  4. However, these democratic system and fundamental right being still intact in the constitution, can be dent from outside.
    1. For instance, when terrorism laws are invoked against journalists, the fundamental right to speech and expression is textually intact in the Constitution but takes a dent outside.
    2. Similarly, when hate speeches against minorities are left unchecked, secularism remains intact in words but not in experiences.
    3. When electoral funding is opaque, democracy is confined to paper.

The court has enough powers to arrest the decline of such constitutionally protected rights, if it realises the effect of this larger trend. Unchecked violations of democratic conditions outside the text of the Constitution and laws would render both the Constitution and the Court without their identities

Here are the key details on the Supreme Court notice regarding the arrest of NewsClick founder under UAPA:

  • Prabir Purkayastha, one of the founders of NewsClick, was arrested by the Delhi police in February 2021 under the UAPA law.
  • NewsClick filed a petition in the Supreme Court challenging his arrest and the use of UAPA charges against him.
  • The petition argues that Purkayastha's arrest violates his fundamental rights and is an attempt to silence the critical media outlet NewsClick.
  • In March 2021, the Supreme Court issued notice to the Delhi police on this petition. It asked the police to respond to NewsClick's claims.
  • The Supreme Court notice is significant because the arrest was made by the police without prior approval from the central government, which is required under UAPA.
  • The court will now examine if there are substantive grounds for the UAPA case and if Purkayastha's arrest followed due process under the law.
  • The Supreme Court's scrutiny on the use of UAPA in this case has wider implications for enforcement of security laws against journalists, activists, etc.
  • The court's decision on the NewsClick petition will determine if the Delhi police misused UAPA powers to suppress critical voices.

In summary, the Supreme Court has intervened to scrutinize the Delhi police's arrest of a NewsClick founder under a strict anti-terror law. Its decision could have bearings on use of such laws against dissent in India.

India’s Import Curbs on Jute Products from Bangladesh

India has imposed immediate restrictions on the import of jute and allied fibre products from Bangladesh. These apply at all Indian land and seaports except Nhava Sheva in Maharash
Share It

GPS Interference

  GPS interference refers to deliberate or unintentional disruption of Global Positioning System (GPS) signals, which are crucial for navigation in aircraft, ships, and ground transport sy
Share It

India’s Civil Nuclear Law Reform:

  India is revising its civil nuclear laws—the Atomic Energy Act (AEA), 1962 and the Civil Liability for Nuclear Damage Act (CLNDA), 2010—to: Attract private and forei
Share It

Secondary Pollutants

A recent study has shed light on an important aspect of India's air pollution crisis: secondary pollutants, which now contribute to nearly one-third of PM2.5 pollution in the country. These pollut
Share It

Myogenesis

Group Captain Shubhanshu Shukla’s Myogenesis experiments on the ISS represent a major leap forward in India’s space research efforts, focusing on the formation and regulation of muscle fib
Share It

Central Sector Scheme of Scholarship for College and University Students (CSSS)

A scholarship scheme under the Pradhan Mantri Uchchatar Shiksha Protsahan (PM-USP) initiative by the Ministry of Education’s Department of Higher Education. It Provides financial assistance to m
Share It

Khasi People

The Meghalaya High Court has admitted a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) concerning the tribal certificate issuance for the Khasi community.This PIL challenges a government decision that has halted th
Share It

Similipal Tiger Reserve

Odisha High Court issued a notice to the Integrated Tribal Development Agency (ITDA) over a ban on Munda tribals from accessing Jayara, a sacred grove inside the tiger reserve.This raised concerns ove
Share It

Begonia nyishiorum

A fascinating new species of flowering plant, Begonia nyishiorum, has been discovered in the East Kameng district of Arunachal Pradesh, further highlighting the rich but underexplored biodiversity of
Share It

Asiatic Wild Dog

Asiatic Wild Dog A new study by the Wildlife Institute of India (WII) has confirmed the return of the dhole (Asiatic wild dog) to Kaziranga-Karbi Anglong Landscape (KKAL) in Assam, after being beli
Share It

Newsletter Subscription


ACQ IAS
ACQ IAS