Daily News Analysis

Concerns about govt.’s fact check unit

stylish_lining

Concerns about govt.’s fact check unit

 

 

Why in the News?

Recently, the Bombay High Court has reserved its verdict relating to challenging of the constitutionality of the Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Amendment Rules, 2023 (IT Rules).

IT Rules, 2023:

  1. The Rules permit a Fact Check Unit (FCU) of the Union Government to identify “fake or false or misleading” online content “related to the business of the Central Government” and require its removal on demand.
  2. This was brought in through 2023 IT Rules which amended the 2021 IT rules.
  3. Changes to Rule 3(1)(b)(v) of the IT Rules, 2021 which deals with responsibilities of intermediaries.
    1. The intermediaries have to make “reasonable efforts” to ensure that users do not “host, display, upload, modify, publish, transmit, store, update, or share any information” which is “identified as fake or false or misleading by a fact check unit of the Central government” in respect of “any business of the Central government.”
    2. Non-compliance with the above provision can attract risk of losing the safe harbour protection provided under Section 79 of the IT Act, 2000 to intermediaries.
    3. The safe harbour safeguard exempts intermediaries from liability for any third-party information made available or hosted by them.

Why has FCU provision been challenged:

  1. The provision shall enable government-led censorship online.
  2. Government shall turn out to be the “prosecutor, the judge, and the executioner” of what constitutes the ‘truth’ online.
  3. But govt. contended that the FCU will only notify contents that are fake, false, or misleading to intermediaries or online platforms, and that intermediaries can choose to take it down or leave it up with a disclaimer.

What did the High Court say?

  1. The amended Rules lack necessary safeguards, no matter how well-intentioned the rules are.
  2. The Rules do not seem to offer protection for fair criticism of the government.
  3. The term “any business of the Central government,” is an ambiguous term and wondered if speeches made ahead of the 2024 Lok Sabha elections would fall within its ambit.
  4. It held that if the consequences of a law are unconstitutional, struck down no matter its good motive.
  5. A judge held that the amendment violates Article 14 of the Constitution by discriminating between false news about the government and other false news.
  6. It questioned the sudden need for a FCU pointing out that the Press Information Bureau (PIB) has been efficiently fact-checking for years.
  7. Terms such as “fake, false, and misleading,” can lead to subjective interpretation i.e., what is misleading for one may not necessarily be misleading for another. 
  8. There is no recourse or remedy recommended for the user in the new rules after the post has been removed or whose account has been suspended by the intermediary after being flagged by the FCU.

INS Nistar

The Nistar is India’s first indigenously designed and constructed Diving Support Vessel, marking a step forward in the country’s naval self-reliance. Key Highlights of the Nistar:
Share It

National Commission for Minorities (NCM)

The National Commission for Minorities is currently facing a leadership vacuum. Since the retirement of the previous Chairperson and members in April 2025, the Commission is awaiting the appointme
Share It

North Eastern Region (NER) District Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) Index Report (2023-24)

The second edition of the North Eastern Region (NER) District Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) Index Report was recently released by NITI Aayog, in collaboration with the Ministry of Developmen
Share It

Corporate Average Fuel Efficiency

The study by Nomura researchers calls for reform of India’s Corporate Average Fuel Efficiency (CAFE) norms, particularly to better protect small cars. Key Highlights of the Study: 1.
Share It

Delhi’s Fuel Ban for Old Vehicles

The Delhi Government has faced considerable backlash following its fuel ban for old vehicles under a directive from the Commission for Air Quality Management (CAQM). The ban was implemented to cur
Share It

India State of Forest Report (ISFR) 2023

The India State of Forest Report (ISFR) 2023 has sparked controversy by attributing part of the negative change in forest cover to the Forest Rights Act (FRA), 2006. The claim has been contested b
Share It

International Treaty on Plant Genetic Resources for Food and Agriculture

The International Treaty on Plant Genetic Resources for Food and Agriculture (ITPGRFA) is a crucial international agreement that plays a key role in the conservation and sustainable use of plant g
Share It

Green Climate Fund (GCF)

The Green Climate Fund (GCF) has recently approved over USD 120 million to support climate resilience projects in Ghana, the Maldives, and Mauritania. This funding aims to assist these countries i
Share It

Quad Critical Minerals Initiative

The Quad Critical Minerals Initiative launched by the United States, India, Australia, and Japan marks a significant shift in global geopolitics and economic strategy, especially with regard to cr
Share It

NITI Aayog's Proposal

NITI Aayog's proposed roadmap to boost India's chemical exports is a significant step toward enhancing the country's position in global chemical supply chains and addressing existing i
Share It

Newsletter Subscription


ACQ IAS
ACQ IAS