Daily News Analysis

Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI)

stylish_lining

 The Supreme Court recently upheld the West Bengal government’s suit against the Union of India regarding the registration and investigation of cases by the CBI. The State challenged the CBI's operations in the State after revoking its general consent in 2018, alleging constitutional overreach and a violation of federalism. This case was filed under Article 131 of the Constitution, which deals with disputes between the Centre and States.

About CBI

  • Establishment: Founded in 1963 following the Santhanam Committee's recommendations on preventing corruption.
  • Ministry: Functions under the Ministry of Personnel, Pension & Public Grievances.
  • Status: A non-statutory and non-constitutional body governed by the Delhi Special Police Establishment (DSPE) Act, 1946.
  • Role: The premier investigative agency in India, coordinating with Interpol and handling major investigations across various domains.
  • Motto: Industry, Impartiality, and Integrity.
  • Vision: To combat corruption, economic and violent crimes, and high technology crimes through rigorous investigations and prosecutions.

Organization and Structure

  • Headed by: Director, assisted by special directors, joint directors, deputy inspector generals, and other senior ranks.
  • Recent Developments: In 2021, ordinances extended the tenure of the CBI Director from two to five years.

Types of Cases Investigated

  • Anti-Corruption
  • Economic Offenses
  • Special Crimes
  • Suo-moto Cases

Consent for Investigation

  • General Consent: States must provide general consent for the CBI to operate in their jurisdiction without seeking permission for each case.
  • States like West Bengal, Punjab, and Telangana have withdrawn general consent, requiring the CBI to seek specific consent for each case.

Important Judicial Pronouncements

  • Common Cause vs Union of India (2019): Established that the CBI Director is to be appointed by a committee including the Prime Minister, Leader of Opposition, and Chief Justice of India or their nominee.
  • CBI v. Dr. RR Kishore (2023): Declared Section 6A of the DSPE Act, 1946 as unconstitutional with retrospective effect.
  • CPIO CBI vs Sanjiv Chaturvedi (2024): Ruled that Section 24 of the RTI Act permits disclosure of information on human rights violations and corruption, despite exemptions.
  • Vineet Narain v Union of India (1997): Struck down the "Single Directive" limiting CBI’s independence.

Concerns with CBI

  • Vacant Positions: Significant vacancies (e.g., 1709 out of 7295 posts) affect operational efficiency.
  • Lack of Transparency: Limited public access to case details and investigation progress.
  • State Consent Issues: Difficulty in investigating cases in states that have withdrawn general consent.
  • Credibility Issues: Past criticisms for mishandling high-profile cases.
  • Administrative Hurdles: Need for prior approval for investigating central government employees can impede corruption probes.
  • Funding and Resources: Inadequate funding and underutilization of resources affect effectiveness.
  • Lack of Autonomy: Administrative control by the Department of Personnel and Training raises concerns about independence.

Recommendations for Improvement

  • Address Vacancies: Monitor and expedite the filling of vacant positions in the CBI.
  • Case Management System: Implement a centralized database to track and publicize case details and progress.
  • Legislative Changes: Enact a new law to define CBI’s status, functions, and powers, with safeguards for impartiality.
  • Recruitment Policies: Limit deputation-based recruitment and increase direct recruitment to strengthen the workforce.
  • Transparency: Publish case statistics and annual reports on CBI’s website.
  • State Consent Clause: Remove the consent requirement for cases posing a national security threat, while addressing states' concerns.

Conclusion

The CBI plays a crucial role in investigating high-profile and sensitive cases across India. Addressing its current concerns and implementing the recommended improvements can enhance its effectiveness, transparency, and independence, ensuring it can better serve its mandate of combating corruption and other serious crimes.

Species in News: Sturgeon

Sturgeons are among the most endangered species groups on Earth, with a lineage dating back to the age of dinosaurs. The WWF report has highlighted alarming trends in illegal sturgeon fishing and trad
Share It

Amendments in Indexation for Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG)

Recently, the Ministry of Finance announced an amendment concerning the Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG) tax on real estate, responding to criticism regarding earlier proposals made in the Budget 2024-2
Share It

Guru Padmasambhava

Recent Developments International Conference: The International Buddhist Confederation (IBC), in collaboration with Nava Nalanda Mahavihara, organized a two-day International Conference on the L
Share It

Citizen Participation Towards Good Governance

Why in the News? The MyGov platform has recently celebrated its 10th anniversary, marking a decade of citizen engagement in governance. About MyGov Platform Launch: Initiated by the Prime
Share It

India-Vietnam Relations

Why in the News? The recent state visit by the Prime Minister of Vietnam to India has strengthened bilateral ties and yielded several key outcomes. Key Outcomes of the Visit Plan of Action
Share It

Hindustan Republican Association (HRA) and the Kakori Train Action

Centenary Celebration of the Kakori Train Action Event: The Government of Uttar Pradesh has launched year-long celebrations starting August 9 to mark the centenary of the Kakori Train Action of
Share It

Exercise Mitra Shakti

Exercise Mitra Shakti is an annual bilateral military exercise between India and Sri Lanka aimed at strengthening joint military capabilities and cooperation, especially for counter-insurgency operati
Share It

Mental health of students

The mental health of students has become a major concern in India, with alarming rates of mental health issues and suicides, particularly among medical students. The National Task Force for Mental Hea
Share It

Gross Environment Product Index (GEPI) in Uttarakhand

Uttarakhand has pioneered the launch of the Gross Environment Product Index (GEPI), marking a significant step towards integrating environmental metrics into economic planning. What is GEPI?
Share It

St. Martin’s Island

St. Martin’s Island is a small island located in the northeastern part of the Bay of Bengal, specifically at the southern tip of the Cox’s Bazar-Teknaf peninsula in Bangladesh. Geograp
Share It

Newsletter Subscription


ACQ IAS
ACQ IAS