Daily News Analysis

Basic Structure doctrine

stylish_lining

Basic Structure doctrine

Why in the News?

The former Chief Justice of the Supreme Court remarked that the Idea of Basic structure Doctrine has a ‘debatable jurisprudential basis’.

Evolution of Basic Structure doctrine:

  1. Shankari Prasad case (1951)
    1. The constitutional validity of the 1st amendment to the constitution that curtailed the fundamental right (FR) of Right to property was challenged.
    2. Verdict:
      • Parliament can amend the Constitution under Article 368 including power to amend the FRs
      • The term ‘law’ under Article 13 includes only ordinary laws and not constitutional amendment acts (CAA). Hence, the Parliament can take away any of the FRs through a CAA and such a law will not be void under Article 13.
  2. Golak Nath case (1967)
    1. The constitutional validity of the 17th amendment act that inserted certain state acts into the Ninth Schedule was challenged.
    2. Verdict:
      • The Supreme Court reversed its earlier stand stating that FRs are given ‘transcendental and immutable’ position and hence cannot be taken away by the Parliament.
      • Article 13 includes CAA within the meaning of law and hence they can be held void for violation of any of the FRs.
  3. Parliament introduced the 24th CAA:
    1. Parliament has the power to take away or abridge any of the FRs under Article 368.
    2. Such CAA will not be considered to be a law under Article 13.
  4. Kesavananda Bharati case (1973):
    1. The SC upheld the 24th CAA, citing that Parliament has powers to abridge or take away any of the FRs.
    2. Doctrine of Basic structure was laid down:
      • The Constituent power of the Parliament under Art.368 cannot be used to alter the basic structure of the constitution.
  5. Reiteration of the Basic Structure doctrine:
    1. Indira Nehru Gandhi case (1975)
      • 39th CAA was invalidated which kept the election disputes involving the Prime Minister and the Speaker, outside the ambit of all courts.
      • This was beyond the power of the parliament as it affected the Basic structure of the constitution.
    2. Minerva Mills case (1980)
      • A provision of 42nd CAA that amended Art 368 to give Parliament unlimited constituent powers and stated that no amendment shall be questioned on any grounds including contravention of FRs in any court of law.
      • This was held invalid as Judicial Review forms an integral part of basic Structure of the Constitution.

 

Elements of Basic Structure Doctrine:

  1. The supremacy of the Constitution,
  2. The rule of law
  3. Effective access to Justice
  4. Independence of the judiciary
  5. Doctrine of separation of powers,
  6. Limited power of the Parliament to amend the Constitution
  7. Sovereign democratic republic
  8. The parliamentary system of government
  9. The principle of free and fair elections
  10. Welfare state
  11. Free and fair elections
  12. Federal character of the Constitution

 

Significance of Basic Structure doctrine:

  1. The judicial innovation has ensured that the power of amendment under Article 368 is not misused by Parliament.
  2. Parliament cannot enjoy any right to repeal, abrogate or destroy the basic features of the constitution.
  3. The Doctrine also ensures protection of democratic principles by preventing Parliament to acquire unlimited powers which can lead to an autocratic state.
  4. Safeguards the identity of the constitution as the basic tenants of the constitution remains unaltered.

Visakhapatnam Declaration on e-Governance

The Visakhapatnam Declaration on e-Governance marks a significant step in the development of digital governance in India, emphasizing inclusive, transparent, and citizen-centric practices. Adopted
Share It

Defamation in India

Recently, a Supreme Court judge raised concerns about the increasing misuse of defamation laws by political figures and private individuals to settle personal and political disputes. The judge sug
Share It

Simultaneous Elections

India's ongoing debate about simultaneous elections or the One Nation, One Election concept has gained momentum, with experts like Arvind Panagariya, Chairman of the 16th Finance Commission, e
Share It

Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) 2025 Summit

The 2025 SCO Heads of State Summit was held in Tianjin, China, marking a significant moment for the organization’s expanding role on the global stage. Key Highlights: Terrorism:
Share It

Production Gap Report 2025

The Production Gap Report 2025 reveals a troubling trend: many countries are planning to increase fossil fuel production well beyond the levels needed to limit global warming to 1.5°C as per t
Share It

India's Roadmap for Fusion Power

India's Institute for Plasma Research (IPR) in Gandhinagar has recently proposed a comprehensive roadmap for the development of fusion power, marking a significant leap towards harnessing fusi
Share It

Dhvani Missile

India's Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) is on the verge of a historic milestone with the upcoming test of Dhvani, a next-generation hypersonic missile that is set to prope
Share It

Global Innovation Index (GII) 2025

India has made remarkable strides in the field of innovation, moving up from 48th position in 2020 to 38th in 2025 among 139 global economies, according to the World Intellectual Property Organiza
Share It

Critical Minerals

India’s first auction of deep-sea blocks for the extraction of critical minerals has been delayed indefinitely after receiving a poor response from bidders. This auction was expected to be a
Share It

CAG Report on States’ Fiscal Health

The Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG) has released its first decadal analysis on the fiscal health of 28 Indian states, revealing significant concerns over the increasing public debt.
Share It

Newsletter Subscription


ACQ IAS
ACQ IAS