Grey-Zone Warfare

Why in the News?

• India’s Chief of Defence Staff highlighted grey-zone warfare at the 9th edition of the Raisina Dialogue. He emphasized its use in regions like the South China Sea and along India’s northern borders.
• Reports also indicate that China is using grey-zone warfare tactics against Taiwan.
• Experts from the US and Europe have characterized recent actions by Russia and China as examples of grey-zone warfare.
   

What is Grey-Zone Warfare?

Definition:

• Grey-zone warfare refers to the use of unconventional tactics and strategies that fall below the threshold of traditional warfare.
• The goal is to harm an adversary without them realizing they are under attack or feeling directly threatened.
• Example: Salami slicing strategy used by China in its territorial expansion in the South China Sea. This involves gradual territorial occupation to test an opponent’s tolerance and response.
   

Characteristics:

• Activities in grey-zone warfare are typically insidious, subtle, and often unseen.
• There are no clear rules, and the front line is not confined to any particular boundary.
• The outcomes of such actions may not be immediately visible, and their long-term impact may not be felt until much later.
• These actions can escalate unpredictably, potentially leading to unintended over-escalation.

Key Activities/Components in Grey-Zone Warfare:

• Cyber Operations:
  • Includes activities like hacking, stealing data, spreading disinformation, and conducting cyber espionage.
  • Disrupts critical infrastructure, political systems, or economies without causing direct physical harm.
  • Example: Cyberattack on Maharashtra’s power grid.
• Information Warfare:
  • Psychological operations to manipulate public opinion, create divisions, and undermine trust in institutions.
  • Includes propaganda, fake news, rumors, and social media manipulation.
• Support to Proxy Forces:
  • Countries may support non-state actors, insurgents, or militias to achieve objectives indirectly.
  • Example: Insurgent or Naxal groups in India receiving support from foreign agencies.
• Economic Coercion:
  • Sanctions, trade restrictions, or manipulation of financial markets are used to undermine a country’s economy or force policy changes.
  • Example: China’s trade restrictions on Australia.
• Political Subversion:
  • Undermining political and administrative systems covertly, including interfering in elections or manipulating political processes.
  • Example: Alleged Russian interference in the US Presidential election.
• Irregular Warfare:
  • Includes tactics like guerrilla warfare, legal and diplomatic maneuvering, and military intimidation.
     

Why is Grey-Zone Warfare Preferred?

• The cost of conventional warfare in the nuclear era is high, and the risk of escalation is profound, making grey-zone tactics more attractive for achieving national objectives.
• Nations with limited resources or military power often prefer grey-zone warfare as a way to achieve strategic goals without direct confrontation.
   

Key Initiatives to Counter Grey-Zone Warfare in India:

• Chief of Defence Staff (CDS):
  • CDS has enhanced coordination among the armed forces, improving their combat effectiveness and integration.
• Modernization of Military Forces:
  • The government promotes technological integration in the military’s systems, focusing on infantry, mechanized forces, artillery, air defense, and aviation.
  • Start-up ecosystem under iDEX is leveraged to foster innovation in defense technologies.
• Self-Reliance in Defense Manufacturing:
  • Initiatives like Defence Procurement Procedure (DAP) 2020 promote indigenous defense production.
• International Cooperation:
  • India has strengthened its defense ties with countries like the US, signing agreements such as the General Security of Military Information Agreement (GSOMIA).
• Cyber Security:
  • Establishment of Indian Computer Emergency Response Team (CERT-In) to tackle cybersecurity threats.
     

Way Forward: Measures to Tackle Grey-Zone Warfare:

• Formation of Theatre Commands:
  • To optimize resources and ensure unity of command across all armed services, the creation of theatre commands is essential.
• Promoting Capability in Key Areas:
  • India should focus on enhancing information warfare, cyber warfare, and space operations. Establishing Special Operations, Cyber, and Space Commands is a priority.
• Active Monitoring and Early Warning Systems:
  • Develop systems to monitor grey-zone activities in various domains (cyber, political, information) to detect early signs and respond swiftly.
• Deterrence through Capability Demonstration:
  • India should regularly showcase its capabilities in cyber, information, and economic warfare to deter adversaries.
  • Clearly communicate red lines and the consequences for unacceptable actions.
• Other Measures:
  • Countering disinformation, preventing funding to insurgent groups, and addressing emerging threats proactively.
     

Raisina Dialogue:

• India’s premier conference on geopolitics and geo-economics, addressing global challenges.
• Hosted by the Observer Research Foundation in partnership with the Ministry of External Affairs.
• 2024 edition theme: Chaturanga: Conflict, Contest, Cooperate, Create.
   

Conclusion:
Grey-zone warfare is becoming a significant challenge in global geopolitics. Countries like China and Russia are using such tactics to achieve strategic objectives without direct military confrontation. India has taken several steps to modernize its defense capabilities, improve coordination among armed forces, and enhance its cybersecurity infrastructure to counter these covert strategies. Moving forward, it is essential for India to bolster its deterrence capabilities, develop advanced monitoring systems, and strengthen international collaborations to effectively tackle the complexities of grey-zone warfare